P.S. 217 Odyssey photo courtesy Matthew Septimus
Rick Hess, education guru at the conservative American Enterprise Institute, says that the whole point of giving parents a choice between charters and traditional public schools is to create competition, which forces both to improve. One form this competition takes is in how they recruit new students. Charters don’t seem to have to jump through the same hoops as TPSs do. We witnessed this recently in Flatbush. Continue reading
Posted in charter schools
Tagged American Enterprise Institute, Brooklyn Dreams Charter School, Edison Project, Joel klein, Judith Brandwein, Magnet Grant Program, Mayor Bloomberg, Michael Bloomberg, Michael R. Bloomberg, national heritage academies, New York charter schools, NY Charter schools, NYC public schools, nyc schools, P.S. 217, rick hess, The Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, The Broad Foundation
Do charter schools raise educational standards? The schools’ proponents say that charters educate more effectively than traditional public schools, and even those that don’t, still create a competitive environment in which traditional public schools are “incentivized” to improve their own teaching methods. Can this logic be disputed?
The pro-charter school argument ignores that charters can hurt overall educational progress by undermining nearby traditional public schools. Charters’ aggressive marketing efforts can force TPSs to expand their own publicity campaigns, diverting money and time that otherwise would have gone to support instruction. A charter’s arrival in a neighborhood also can demoralize a public school’s leadership and parents, who view the interloper as a competitor for space and dollar resources and community support. But it is outside the schoolhouse walls that charters may do their most lasting damage, if they create or exacerbate social divisions in the community. How this plays out depends on the neighborhood, and the quality of its traditional public school. Continue reading
CityPragmatist 