Charter Commission Kick-off: Cheesecake and Undercurrents

First came the cheesecake: Brooklyn BP Marty Markowitz greeted the 2010 NYC Charter Revision Commission members at their first public meeting, at the NYC College of Technology in downtown Brooklyn, and gifted each one with Junior’s cheesecake.

Then commission chair Matthew Goldstein explained the purpose of the meeting to an audience of about 75, and invited his colleagues to introduce themselves. When the intros progressed across the crowded stage to commission member Carlo Scissura, Scissura leaned back and deferred to colleague Hope Cohen, who had been forced to sit behind him when the dais got too crowded for all 15 commission members. Goldstein, a mathematician by training, joked about this as being an example of “a packing problem.” It was not his last mathematical allusion. Our take: The commission’s March 3rd appointment date didn’t leave enough time to hire the staff members who could prepare for a public meeting scheduled only two weeks later.

Goldstein impressed us as a strong leader, stepping through his agenda with ease. After introductions, he took pains to pay “tribute” to commission colleague Anthony Crowell, a senior Bloomberg counsel, an acknowledged charter expert, and a veteran of five previous charter revision commissions.

Chairman Goldstein announced that the commission will try hard to place proposals on the 2010 ballot, a sentiment echoed after the meeting by commission member Stephen Fiala. To achieve this, Goldstein said, the commission will have to adhere to a “very aggressive” schedule, formulating its final proposals by the end of August and filing them with the Board of Elections by September 3.

The balance of the meeting consisted of a charter history and introduction provided by City attorneys Spencer Fisher and Lisa Grumet, and several motions advanced by Goldstein, all approved unanimously and without discussion. These affirmed Goldstein’s authority to select and hire the commission’s staff, set forth the commission’s intended methodology, and endorsed goals consistent with the “core values” that Goldstein expected the commission to adhere to. These goals included improving “accountability and transparency of government,” making government “more effective,” and making “our civic life more participatory and more representative.”

In the audience, leaders of the city’s Independence Party sat quietly and considered the testimony they will deliver when the commission conducts public hearings in April. One of them, NY County Chair Cathy L. Stewart, told us that her party’s goal will be to convince the charter commission to recommend non-partisan City elections: not an unlikely target with a commission appointed by Michael R. Bloomberg, whose 2003 appointees did the same thing, but were rejected by voters.

Commission General Counsel Rick Schaffer

Also in the audience: CUNY General Counsel Rick Schaffer, whom CUNY Chancellor Goldstein said would be serving (pro bono) as General Counsel to the 2010 Charter Revision Commission. Schaffer’s designation raises an interesting question: How will he interact with commission member Anthony Crowell, himself a lawyer and charter expert. As we commented before, we expect Crowell to play a key role in making sure that the commission’s agenda doesn’t deviate too far from the mayor’s.

One response to “Charter Commission Kick-off: Cheesecake and Undercurrents

  1. Impressive and hopeful first meeting! Thanks for your diligent attention!! – Nancy

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s